6Sense: Generating New Possibilities in the New Internet.
Produced by: IPv6 Summit, Inc.

The Global Information Grid, IPv6 and Web Services
Kent Gladstone

The Force Transformation's success depends on the success of the Global Information Grid (GIG). The GIG appears unwieldy at first glance, but after defining all of the various components, it seems much more manageable. Each component has its own unique set of challenges and opportunities associated with it. All parts are intertwined; some may stand alone, and others may have dependencies. The bottom line is that they all support the data.

The GIG is the basis for Network Centric Operations. Network Centric Operations "refers to the combination of emerging tactics, techniques, and technologies that a networked force employs to create a decisive ...advantage."i This concept requires us to visit all layers of communications to ensure success. Currently, the DoD is visiting several of these layers, as seen in Figure 1, in order to optimally share information among the network's constituents.

Figure 1

Figure 1: 7 Layers of Communications

The adage "it is all about the data" holds more truth today than ever before. Force Transformation means Net Centric Operations get the data to the edge users precisely when they need it. Net Centric Operations have created a new metaphor of data usage by posting it before it is fully processed, allowing for near real-time use, with each user become both a consumer and producer. This concept is becoming known as the Net Centric Operating Environment.

In order for this to work, data must be standalone: it can not be tied to a single application. The data gathered by an unmanned aerial vehicle should allow a user to place the data independent of the application or the geographical location from which it was gathered. The user can create a graphical or visual report, or put the tracks on a map without performing any special data manipulation. Meta-tagging allows data to be independent of its application. Additionally, enabling the user to search for data without having to know where it resides requires the use of web services. Web services, as defined by techencyclopedia.com, are "web-based applications that dynamically interact with other Web applications using open standards."

In order for the data to get to its destination, we must have the infrastructure in place. This entails installing more optical fiber and cellular towers, and building a configuration grid around the world that allows for transmission across non-service areas.

The technologies that allow a message to get from the source to the destination with a high level of assurance are the Internet Protocol (IP) in conjunction with the Transmission Control Protocol (TCP). TCP makes the transmission reliable. Without TCP, IP can be routed but it is not reliable. IP packets that are routed contain source and destination descriptions. TCP runs on end-stations and communicates about whether IP packets have arrived and how quickly they should be sent.

Two important aspects of IPv6 are a) much larger address capability (128 bit versus 32 bit), and b) the capability to deal more effectively with Quality of Service and security (although organizations are still struggling with how to handle these areas). Address size is important for a variety of reasons. According to Cisco (see Figure 2), the United States owns 70% of the addresses worldwide, a fact that explains why other countries are pushing IPv6 forward at an accelerated rate. China has mandated the protocol, Korea is developing a parallel IPv6 network, and several European countries have begun to implement it. Most countries are in a wait-and-see mode, both for the U.S. to take the lead and to allow vendors to start putting out IPv6-capable systems. Another important aspect of addresses is that they can be used to tag just about anything imaginable. For example, an auto manufacturer might use them to put a sensor in your car to track its use, or the Marine Corps could use them to track inventory. A final key note about IPv4 addresses is that their current growth rate may begin to affect the router tables that keep track of all this information. This in turn will negatively affect both latency and throughput.

An important aspect of IPv6 is its development for wireless components, such as the Joint Tactical Radio System (JTRS). A class of mobile communications is referred to as a MANET (Mobile Ad hoc Network). MANETs allow communications between mobile sources and destinations to be routed by other mobile nodes; in other words, the network connectivity is dynamic, as the nodes comprising the network are also mobile.

Figure 2

Figure 2: IP Address Allocation History

How does all of this fit in with data? The key term is web services. If an automaker wants to be able to ping your car and get data out of it, he will first need a unique address for your car, and then he will need to actually retrieve the data. IPv6 will guarantee the unique address for the component and make it searchable; web services will allow automakers' accountants, engineers, and quality control people to track the performance of the vehicle. In other instances, dealers will be able to track the vehicle's maintenance history. These are just a few examples of use the data uploaded from the vehicle. IPv4 simply cannot supply the number of unique addresses to all of the potential devices that the commercial industry and government may want to ultimately contact.

Web services began with the inception of business-to-business concepts. Web services data language (WSDL) has evolved using XML (and several other media), and describes the protocol used for the service.

The Defense Information Systems Agency (DISA) has begun developing the basis for this through the Net Centric Enterprise Services (NCES) program. NCES provides the foundation for data discovery and search, messaging and alerts, and the security for authority and authentication. In the meantime, OSD/NII has come forth with Horizontal Fusion as part of its research and development, in its attempt to web-enable data from DoD sources among the various agencies and Services.

The result facilitates coordinating, testing, certifying and encouraging the services to meta-tag their data, make it shareable, and make it usable to the edge commander who needs to know the equipment and personnel he has available for a battle operation. This will also provide intelligence gathered at the intra-agency level for special operations people planning an insertion (and will challenge security policies as they stand today).

On other fronts, the Services are slowly embracing web services for strategic, logistics and tactical use. Horizontal Fusion has been focused primarily on the Intelligence Community, providing data for the battlefield commander; it has included common operation picture tracks, weather information, and other utilities that the field commander may find useful. Other uses such as field medicine, satellite tracking, network node management, radio configuration, and sensor management are areas that web-services can also provide to users through the network. For this to be successful, the number of sensors, servers, PDAs and other elements that could potentially send or receive data all require IP addresses. Without expanded IP addresses in the future, web services could be unnecessarily limited.

Outside the DoD, web services can provide valuable information to public safety officers, health services, field technicians, oil companies, and ranchers with valuable information in their areas of interest.

There are caveats which the success of IPv6 and web services, (as described in this paper) depends upon. For starters, there needs to be a robust level 1 and 2 infrastructure. Unless wires and airwave towers are in place, success will be limited. Additionally, the node address mediation of one network IP encountering another network IP has not been completely resolved in the IETF community. For example, if the packet is going from Cingular to Nextel, how will this hop work? This is particularly true for mobile systems such as cell phones, and may affect more static components that are moved from the manufacturer's plant to an unknown destination (both might remain within the same network, so that there would be no problem, but they might end up on separate networks). In order to take better advantage of web services, IP version 6 needs further maturation, especially in mobility and security.

In summary, web services and IPv6 are enabling technologies that make possible the concepts of Force Transformation and Network Centric Operations. The DoD as well as Federal, State and Local Governments can take advantage of this technology - as can the public safety and consumer goods industries. The manufacturing industry ought to look closely at these capabilities, and the potential for increasing marketing demographics, which in the end could mean better products for the consumers, and more information and income for industry.

i Military Transformation: A Strategic Approach. Office of Force Transformation, Department of Defense, Fall 2003